i have many issues with the Harry Potter books/movies but one of them is Peter Pettigrew’ character. Like JKR made the only Gryffindor antagonist be ugly and fat (even pre animagus) and implied that the sorting hat made a mistake putting him in Gryffindor by making him a hatstall and a coward.
Like Peter should have been such an interesting character since he was the main antagonist that’s not Slytherin and he betrayed all his friends but instead he is boring and makes no sense.
So what if instead of fear it were some of his Gryffindor traits that pushed him to the dark, like he actually believed in Voldemort’s cause and so by joining him he actually saw himself as being brave or being a hero and he was too stubborn, reckless, and prideful to consider other ways. And yes, you’d need a backstory on why Peter came to the conclusion Voldemort is right, but it would be way more interesting and scarier and more tragic.
Instead of poor foolish Peter being too scared to say no to Voldemort you get cunning Peter choosing Voldemort over his friends.
TLDR: Peter Pettigrew should never have been portrayed as weak and foolish and cowardly because it diminishes the tragedy of his betrayal and undermines the fact that he was a Gryffindor.

hideousocean